Sarasota FL

Did you ever wonder what the restaurant, grocery store, department store or bank that you shop or patronize while in Sarasota, FL used to be?  Maybe not, but if you have, here are some of them listed by street name and street number (the list will be continuously expanded and updated).  Credit for much of the information goes to the Sarasota County History Center and the archives of the Sarasota Herald-Tribune and Sarasota Journal.

1st Street
1287 - The Bijou Café Restaurant (since the mid 80's) used to be a Texaco service station from the 1920's-30's era into the 60's.  In between, it was an art studio in the mid to late 70's.
1426 - This was the location of the Plaza Restaurant (shown below) from 1928 to the mid-70's, It then became Merlin's Restaurant until the early 90's and was torn down a few years later in 1997 to make way for new development. 
1544 - This used to be Raul's Spanish Restaurant from 1968 to 1997. It was later Oswald Trippe And Company Insurance.

17th Street
3251 (unit 10) - Pizza Hut (since the mid-to-late 80's) in the Northeast Plaza Shopping Center
used to be T.V. Engineers Of Kensington Park from the late 70's to mid 80's.
3251 (160) - Fat Daddio's Pizza (since 2017) in the Northeast shopping plaza used to be Honey Crust Pizzeria from about the early-to-mid 80's until 2010.  In between, it was Rico's Pizzeria & Pasta House from 2010 to 2017.  Honey Bees Ladies Apparel was here prior to Honey Crust.
3251 (220) - Big Lots (since 1993) in the Northeast shopping plaza used to be a Sears Surplus Store from the mid 80's to 1993.
3564 - Wet Pets SRQ (since late 2016) used to be a Pizza Hut restaurant from 1979 to about the mid 00's.
3572 - Hungry Howie's used to be a KFC restaurant from 1977 until the mid 90's.
3590 - Realty Services used to be a 7-Eleven store from about the mid 70's to early 90's.

Bahia Vista Street
2045 - Roadside Rib Shack used to be a Kentucky Fried Chicken restaurant from about 1969 to 1984.
3434 - Yoder's Restaurant used to be known as Blue Gate Restaurant from about 1975 to the early-to-mid 80's. Photo: Blue Gate Restaurant in 1977.
3737 (11) - Alma Sue's Quilts used to be the popular Fifty's Diner from about 1994 to 2002. It then became Kreamy Kustard Frozen Delights.  Below: Fifty's Diner

Bay Road
1800 - Sunset Chevrolet (since 1979) used to be Altman Chevrolet from 1965 (moved from Central Ave.) to 1979.  Below: Altman Chevrolet
1902 - Rico's Pizzeria & Pasta House (since 1998) used to be Bagel Inn from about 1978 to 1998.

Bay Shore Road
3701 - Sarasota Jungle Gardens has been a popular Sarasota tourist attraction since 1939.  Below: Entrance sign to Sarasota Jungle Gardens from North Tamiami Trail in the 70's.

Beach Road (Siesta Key)
431 - Condominiums now exist on the site that was the location of the Blue Gentian Restaurant from about the mid-to-late 50's to the early 70's when the name was changed to The Inn Between Restaurant until the mid 90's.  It then became the Beach Café.

Bee Ridge Road
2010 - Before being torn down in 1998 to make way for Walgreens, a KFC restaurant was here from late 1974 to the mid-to-late 90's.  Photo: Kentucky Fried Chicken shortly before it's opening in 1974.

2020 -Also torn down in 1998, this was the home of the Pizza Shanty restaurant from the mid 70's to mid 80's.  Previously, it had been Don & Eunice's Restaurant from before 1960 and was later American Sun Out from the late 80's to mid-to-late 90's. Photo: Pizza Shanty as seen through a car window it appears.

2111 - The Eye Associates (since 1992, was also Kantor Eye Associates) used to be a European Health Spa fitness center (1973 to 1981), then Sarasota All-American Fitness Centers from 1981 to about 1989.  At right: Sarasota All-American Fitness Center in 1981 flanked by the "Atlas" statue that was left over from the European Health Spa

2223 - Iverson's Furniture (since the late 50's and called Iverson's Bee Ridge Thrift Shop in its early years) used to be Taylor Furniture.
2300 (103) - Total Tennis at The Colonnade (since 2012) used to be the Persnickety Cat gift shop from about the mid 80's to 2012.
2407 - S’macks Burgers & Shakes (since 2013) used to be an Amoco service station (Bee Ridge Amoco) in the 50's all the way into the early-to-mid 00's.  The station was rebuilt in the early 70's.
2738 -  Fred Astaire Dance Studio (since 1979) used to be the location of Brookside Grocery from at least the late 40's until 1974. It then became Drury's Hardware
2773 - The home of Frankie's Pizza from 1973 into the early-to-mid 00's.  It later became Aioli Grill Italian Express in 2005, Viva Sarasota Café and San Diego Tacos To Go.
2833 - Roni's Café (since 2016) used to be a Chicken Unlimited Restaurant from late 1973 or early 1974 to 1984. The Buttery Restaurant opened in 1985 for well over ten years and it then became Dina's Family Restaurant in the late 90's.  Pegusas Greek Restaurant and Fiona's Too were here between the mid 00's and 2016.
3530 - Gettel Nissan (since 1998) used to be Campbell Motors from 1981 to the early 90's, then was Sarasota Nissan-Jeep.
3571 - Starbucks (since 2001) was a Texaco service station for over 35 years.
3701 - Denny's restaurant (since 1994) used to be the Cypress Inn restaurant (1976 to 1993). In between, it was a Peg Leg Pete's Restaurant.
3740 -  A bank was built in 2011 on the location that used to be Wag's Restaurant from the mid 80's to early-to-mid 90's and Mel's Diner from the mid-90's to 2008.
3750 - Big Lots (since about 2003) used to be a Woolco department store (1974 to early 1983). It then became a House Works store (1983 to 1987) and Service Merchandise catalog store (late 80's to 2002).  Below: The parking lot is full at Woolco on Bee Ridge Rd. in March 1974 for opening day.

3828 - McDonald's has been here since the late 70's and was rebuilt in the mid 00's.
3900 - Residential property now occupies the area that was the site of the Bee Ridge Drive-In Theater from 1969 to 1981.
4020 - This used to be a Wendy's Restaurant from 1986 to early 2017.
4050 - Public Storage (since 2015) used to be a Scotty's Hardware store from 1968 to 2003 and later Bee Ridge Self Storage.  Below: Scotty's Hardware closing sale in 2003.
4084 - Southern Steer Butcher (since 2017) used to be Sarasota Bicycle Center from the late 80's to 2016. Earlier, it was Handy Dandy Grocery (late 50's to mid 60's), Lil' General Store (mid 60's to early 70's) and Bee Ridge Meats (early 70's to mid-to-late 80's).
4086 - Bee Ridge Pharmacy used to be Bee Ridge Sub Shop from about 1983 into the 00's.  It had been Seagraves Sub Shop in the early 80's.
4116 - Cracker Jack's Pub (since mid-to-late 90's) used to be a Kentucky Fried Chicken restaurant from 1980 to about 1995.
4118 - Signs In One Day used to be The Loft Bar & Lounge from the mid 60's to the mid-to-late 70's. when it became The Country Club.  It was later ABC Liquors from 1984 to 1998 before moving down the street and then Frisky Business Pet Daycare.
4230 - Winn Dixie Supermarket (since 2014) used to be a Kwik Chek Supermarket (renamed as Winn Dixie in the 70's) from late 1965 to the late 90's.  It then became a Kash N' Karry Supermarket in 2001 before being converted to Sweetbay in 2005 until becoming Winn Dixie (again) in 2014.
4290 - Dino's Pizza (since late 1978) in the Southeast Shopping Plaza used to be Southern States Restaurant in the early-to-mid 70's.
4301 - CVS Pharmacy (since 2000 - converted from Eckerd Drugs in 2004) was built in the former location of a Pizza Hut Restaurant (mid 70's to late 90's and torn down in 2000). A Tee Pee Drive-In Restaurant was here in the early-to-mid 70's.
4401 - Batteries Plus (since mid-to-late 90's) used to be a 7-Eleven store from the late 70's to mid 90's.
4404 - Save-A-Lot (since 2003) in Palm Plaza used to be a Grand Union supermarket (1982 to 1984), then converted into a Kash N Karry supermarket (1984 to early 00's) when Grand Union closed their Florida stores.
4458 -  Oriental Buffet (since 1999) in Palm Plaza used to be Pictures and Pitchers movie and dinner theatre in 1983 and 1984.  It was also Mrs. Appleton's restaurant from 1986 to 1996 and Maggie's Buffet from 1996 to 1998. 
4460 - Before being rebuilt into multiple stores in Palm Plaza, this used to be a Food Fair (converted to Pantry Pride in 1969) Supermarket from late 1965 to early 1979. It was later Carpet Remnant World in the early 80's.
5864 -  Panera Bread (since 2008) used to be Woody's B-B-Q (opened in 1993). Prior to that, it was Pepper's Bar and Grill.

Cattlemen Road
3941 - Burlington Coat Factory (since 2001) used to be a Kmart department store (1982-2000).
4041 - Regions Bank (since 2007) used to be Stockyard Steakhouse (1992 to 2001) and then Auntie Pasta Restaurant. Prior to that, it was Ponderosa Steakhouse (mid-to-late 80's to early 90's) and Walkabout Steak Station.  Below: Stockyard Steakhouse

4059 - Madfish Grill Restaurant (since 1999) used to be a bank (Barnett Bank and later SouthTrust Bank) from the mid 80's to late 90's.
4088 - Tile Outlets of America in Centergate Plaza (since 2013) used to be a Home Depot from about the mid 80's until moving to their current location across the street in September 1994.  It was later a Waccamaw's HomePlace store from 1996 to 2001, Book Market (2002) and Picture Factory.
4092 - Ollie’s Bargain Outlet (opened in November 2017) used to be a Sports Authority from 1996 to 2016.

Central Avenue
1 - White Tower Restaurant (not to be confused with White Castle or Royal Castle) was here from about the late 50's to the mid-to-late 80's.  Below: White Tower Restaurant

Central Sarasota Parkway
4840 - Kohl's Department Store (since 2011) used to be an Albertsons Market from 1999 to 2006.

Clark Road

2820 - Now a dentist office, this used to be Caribbean Pie Company from the late 90's before becoming Latitude 23.5°  Coffee & Tea in 2004.  Earlier, it had been Drive Through Beverage Center for much of the 80's and Valentino's Pizza & Beverage from the early to mid 90's.  Photo: Caribbean Pie Company
2856 - Sparkle-Brite Pool Supplies used to be a Chicken Unlimited restaurant from 1974 to about 1979, becoming Moon's Landing, then a Dairy Queen in the early 80's.  By 1984, the restaurant was turned into First Presidential Savings Bank through the early 90's.
2881 (unit 7) - Winn Dixie Supermarket (since 2014) actually started out as a Winn Dixie from 1977 to the late 90's. It later became a Kash N' Karry Supermarket in 2001 before being converted to Sweetbay in 2005.  It then converted back into a Winn Dixie in 2014.
2881 (25) - SweetBerries (since 2002) used to be a Long John Silver's restaurant from 1977 to the early 00's.
2951 - Ashton Lake Condominiums (since mid-to-late 80's) are in the location that used to be Tommy Bolt's Golden T Golf Club from the early-to-mid 60's to the mid 80's.
3206 - Tony's Used Appliances used to be Little Star Bantam Market (late 1961 to mid 60's) and then a U-Totem Food Store from the mid 60's to mid-to-late 70's.  It later became a Quickie Food Store (late 70's to early 80's), Gulf Coast One Stop Food Store (early 80's to mid-to-late 80's) and Danny's Deli before becoming Certified Reconditioned Appliances in the mid 90's.
3404 - Tijuana Flats Restaurant (since 2009) used to be a Boogie Woogie record store from 1989 to 2008.
3414 - Jersey Mike's Subs (since 2016) used to be a Subway Restaurant from late 1987 to late 2014 or early 2015.
3416 - Papa John's Pizza (since mid-90's) used to be a Zack's Famous Frozen Yogurt store from the late 80's to early-to-mid 90's.
3428 - Publix Supermarket has been operating at this location at Beneva Village Shoppes since 1987.
3555 - The former ABC Fine Wine & Spirits (1993 to 2017) used to be a Lil' General food store (mid 70's to 1984), then Circle K (1984 to 1992).
3577 - Verizon Wireless (since 2014) used to be a Shamrock Service Station in the 70's before becoming Safeway Oil by the decade's end. It would become a bank in 1980 (Naples Federal Savings) until about 2012 while changing its name a few more times (Banc Florida, First Union and Liberty Savings Bank).
3578 - Beef O'Brady's (since 2012) at Beneva Village Shops used to be Shaner's Restaurant from about the early 00's to 2011.  Earlier, it was Ernie's Restaurant (late 80's to early 90's), East End Bar & Grill and Dakota Bar & Grill.
3580 - 7-Eleven and Mobil used to be a Standard (later Chevron-shown below) service station from about 1974 to the late 90's.
4031 - The Original Egg Restaurant (since 2010 and formerly The Broken Egg) used to be Atlanta Bread Company from the mid-to-late 00's.
5304 - Jimmy Johns (since 2014) adjacent to the Palmer Market store used to be a combination A&W Root Beer and Long John Silver's Restaurant from about 2003 to 2005. It would then become an Arby's Restaurant (Arby's sign below from 2006) and later a Just Pizza Restaurant.  The restaurant opened in early 2001 as a Hardee's.

5733 - Tap 72 (since 2016) used to be a Popeye's Chicken restaurant (1990 to about 1994).  In between, it was a Wings N Weenies restaurant from the mid 90's until 2015.

Clark Center Avenue (buildings appear to be on Clark Road)
5947 - Livingston's Amusement Center (since 2005) used to be a Lowe's Home Improvement Center from 1986 to 1989. After being used as a temporary office for Sarasota County, it became an Albritton Fruit store in 1995

Derek Avenue (buildings appear to be on Clark Road)
5825 - Starbucks Coffee (since early 2014) used to be a KFC Restaurant from the early 00's to 2012.
Below:KFC on Derek Ave. before closing in 2012.

Fruitville Road
1515 - Formerly known as 1515 3rd Street, this retail center was once the site of a Margaret Ann (later converted to Kwik Chek and Winn Dixie) grocery store from about the early 50's to the mid 80's, when it became a Food Way Market.  Later businesses at this site included House Of Golf (opened in the late 80's) and Empire Gallery.
1947 - Walgreens (since late 1996) is at the location previously occupied by the Old Heidelberg Castle restaurant from 1972 to 1995. It was previously the American Legion Coliseum and originally a Studebaker dealership. Below: Old Heidelberg Castle
2250 - Sarasota Lanes opened its doors in August 1958 and is still operating at the same location today.
2851 - At the corner of Fruitville Rd. and Tuttle Ave. used to be Texas Jim's Animal Land & Zoo from the 1935 to 1965.
3192 - A real estate office built in 2001 now occupies the area that used to be the location of The Ranch House tavern from at least the mid 50's until about the late 70's.
3511 - McDonald's has been at this location since 1979.
3550 - Walgreens (since 2005) is at the location previously occupied by a Burger King (mid 80's to 2004). Restaurants previously in this spot included Ronnick's (1958 to mid 60's), N.E. Oyster House, Smoke House, Raw Oyster House, Corky's, The Place and The Meating Place (opened in 1980).
3554 - Before being knocked down to make way for Walgreens, a Grandy's Country Cookin' Restaurant stood here from 1984 to 1996 or 1997, then China Star restaurant from 1997 to 2004. A 7-Eleven store preceded Grandy's in this location in the 70's and early 80's.
4652 - CJ Autos of Sarasota used to be Waters Gulf Service from 1958 into the 80's, when it would become Waters Seventy Six.  It later became Waters Citgo in the 90's.

4933 - Before being rebuilt in the mid to late 00's while a BP station(was earlier Phillips 66), this Marathon station used to be Joe's Handi Stop, operated by Joe Shively, affectionately known as "Peanut Joe" from the mid 70's to 1992.
5020 - Inkawasi Peruvian Restaurant,(since 2016) used to be a KFC Restaurant from 1988 to 2011.  It then became Antoine's Restaurant (2013 to 2015 before moving to N. Tuttle Ave.) and Maemi's Chicken.
Gulf Gate Drive
2184 - Fashion Focus Hair Academy (since 2000) used to be Gulf Gate Liggett Rexall Drugs from the 70's to the 90's

Goodrich Avenue
225 - Stonegate Bank on the corner of Fruitville and Goodrich used to be the location of the Nehi Bottling Company from about the late 1920's to 1977.  The building was destroyed after a fire in 1983.

Hillview Street
1859 - Pacific Rim Restaurant (since 1999) used to be the location of Walpole Pharmacy from 1955 to 1997.

Honore Avenue
705 - 7-Eleven (since about the early-to-mid 70's) used to be Gant's Grocery, which opened in 1964 after moving from 709 Honore Ave.
817 - Alvis Heating & Cooling and Muse Emporium used to be the very popular Trevino's Mexican Restaurant from 1977 to about 1986 before moving to N. Beneva Rd.  Even before that, it was Sister Sundries' store and gas station (Esso at one time) through the 60's and into the 70's. Below: Trevino's Mexican Restaurant

John Ringling Boulevard
465 - Shore Clothing and Restaurant was the location of Ruby Tuesday's Lounge from 1978 to about the early 90''s.
470 - Blue Dolphin Café (since about 1998) was previously the Buttery Coffee Shop for at least 25 years.
Main Street
1319 - Torn down in 2013 to make way for The Jewel condominiums, this used to be Sports Page Bar & Grille from the late 80's to 2013.  It had been a travel agency and art studio before becoming Ziggy's Grill in the mid 80's.
1341 - Clasico Cafe And Bar (since 2013) used to be Charlie's News from 1974 to 1997 and Sarasota News & Books from 1997 to 2009. Before 1974, it was Club Tavern (late 60's) and Landchess Lounge (early 70's) and after 2009, it was Café Palm.  Below:Charlie's News in 1974.
1345 -An office center since the late 80's, this used to be Foley's Follies lounge from the early-to-mid 70's to the early 80's. From the 50's to early 70's, it was primarily a coffee shop under various names (White Wing, Russo's and Esquire).
1355 -Two Senorita's Restaurant (since 1994) used to be Coley's Restaurant from the early-to-mid 80's to about 1993.
1364 -Sears, Roebuck & Co. Department Store was here from at least 1938 until moving to Sears Shopping Plaza (now Midtown Plaza) in 1960.
1395 -First Watch Restaurant (since early 1992) used to be The Sport Shop dress and clothing store from 1933 to 1991 after three years at 356 (later renumbered 1464) Main St.  Levy's store was here before switching locations with The Sport Shop in 1933.
1396 - Badger Drugs operated here from at least as far back as 1905 until the early-to-mid 60's.
1400 - Located at Five Points (the intersection of Main, Pineapple and Central), the location of Fit2Run used to be a bank in the 1910's until 1933.  It would then become Liggett Drugs from about 1938 to 1948 until moving up the street to 400 Main (renumbered to 1500 Main in 1953). Madison Drugs would take over this location until the late 50's when it was reacquired and became Liggett-Rexall Drugs until a fire badly damaged the building on April 1, 1979.  The building was rebuilt in 1985 and was then called Kress International Plaza, consisting of several businesses.  A major tenant here was Patrick's Restaurant on the first floor until moving to 1481 Main in 2011.
1401 - Plaza At Five Points occupies the area that used to be Palmer First National Bank an Trust Company of Sarasota from 1929 until acquired by Southeast Bank in 1976.  Southeast became First Union in 1991 and the building was torn down in 1999 after being vacant for a few years.
1428 - This used to be Cheap Clothes denim resale shop from about 1977 to 1983.  It had previously been Lerner Shops from the mid 50's to mid 70's after expanding from 1424 Main and replacing Nathan's Clothing. 
1442 - The historic Kress building used to be the S.H. Kress Company 5 and 10 store from 1932 to about the mid 70's.
1451 - Since the late 70's after reconstruction, multiple businesses from 1451 to 1463 Main occupy the area that used to be Penney's (JC Penney) Department Store from at least the 1930's until moving to Southgate Plaza in 1961.
1460 - Now multiple businesses from 1460 to 1464 Main, this used to be McCrory's 5 and 10 store from 1923 to early 1992.
1481 - Patrick's 1481 Restaurant (since 2011) used to be Norton Camera Center from 1962 to 1997 when it was converted to a Wolf Camera store.  It then became a Re/Max office in 2007 and Braza Brazilian Steakhouse in 2009.
1500 - Blue Mercury Spa at the corner of Main and Lemon used to be Ellie's Book & Stationary from 1972 to 1981, when the name was changed to The Downtown Store until about the late 90's. Earlier, it was Bay Drugs (Walgreen Agency) from 1940 to the late 40's, Liggett-Rexall Drugs from about the late 40's to 1960 and King Dollar Stores in the early 60's.
1537 - Wild Ginger Sushi & Asian Cuisine (since 2015) used to be The Cotton Shop from at least the 1940's to the mid 80's.  Restaurants here from 1987 to 2015 included Far East Gourmet (opened in 1987), Golden Dragon (opened in 1992), Yume Sushi (moved across the street), The Famous Tavern and Top Sushi. Below: The Cotton Shop around 1980 during a parade on Main Street.  Domestic Finance is to the left.
1783 - At about where the SunTrust building sits today used to be location of the legendary Smack Drive-in restaurant (below) from 1932 to 1959.
1801 - Michael Saunders Real Estate (since the mid-to-late 80's) used to be the location of Saprito Bros. Fruit Company from at least the 1940's until about the mid 70's.
1802 - Reese Chevron (since 1953 and still pumps your gas!) used to be Hamilton's Standard Service from at least the 1930's ubtil the early 50's.  Below: Reese Chevron in 2006.

1944 - The Main Bar Sandwich Shop (since 1958) used to be The Main Bar going back at least to the 40's.
1993 - Regal Hollywood Stadium 20 movie theatre (since 1997) is at the location that for many years was occupied by the Maas Brothers department store from 1956 to 1991. After being utilized by the International Marketplace in the early-to-mid 90's, the Maas Brothers building was torn down in 1996.  Below: Maas Brothers Department Store in 1956.

Marina Plaza 
2 - Marina Jack Restaurant (since 1968) used to be Marina-Mar Restaurant from 1963 to 1968.

Midnight Pass Road
5831 - Dolphin Bay condominiums (since 1998) were built where the popular Magic Moment Restaurant stood from 1977 to 1991. Prior to that, it had been the Marker 69 restaurant.
6101 - Summer Cove condominiums (since 2007) were built where another popular Siesta Key restaurant, The Summerhouse operated from 1975 to 2004.

N Boulevard of the Presidents
13 - A group of retail shops now occupy the former location of the Tail O' The Pup Restaurant from about the late 50's to the early 90's.

North Beneva Road
501 (180) - The former Sweetbay Supermarket (2005 to 2013) in the Town and Country Plaza used to be a Grand Union (see photo)Supermarket from September 1981 to early 1984 when Grand Union sold their Florida stores.  It then became a Kash N' Karry Supermarket from 1984 to 2005.
501 (280) - Beall's Department Store (since 2000) in the Town and Country Plaza used to be a J.Byrons (later shortened to Byrons) Department Store from 1979 to 1996, then became Upton's until late 1999.
501 (430) - Now vacant, this used to be a Dairy Queen from 1979 to about 2000.
501 (800) - The former Kmart Department Store in the Town and Country Plaza opened in November 1978 and operated all the way until a round of Sears/Kmart store closings shuttered the store in March 2017.
935 (101) - Publix Supermarket has been operating at this location at the Sarasota Commons plaza since 1980.
935 - The restaurant with the rotating buffet at the Sarasota Commons plaza from the early to mid-to-late 80's was Duff's Smorgasbord
935 (801) - USPS (since 1998) at the Sarasota Commons plaza used to be Luria's catalog store from late 1980 to early 1997.

North Honore Avenue

1701 - Goodwill Industries (since late 2006) used to be a Food Lion supermarket (opened in 1991) before being converted to Kash N Karry around 1998 or 1999 and lasting until early 2004. At left: Kash N Karry in January 2004.  At right: Accompanying Kash N' Karry sign that was still standing in front of the building in 2014, ten years after the store closed and then became a Goodwill store in 2006.

North Lime Avenue
110 - Sarasota Discount Pharmacy was once a Terry Shulman's, described as a health, beauty aid, cosmetic and vitamin store by the Sarasota Journal, from 1978 to the mid 80's (pictured below in 1978). Below: Terry Shulman's in Colonial Plaza in 1978.

200 - Save A Lot (since the 90's) used to be an A & P supermarket from 1963 to 1978.  It then became Great Scot (1979 to 1981) and Foodway (1981-1982) supermarkets.  It was also Footware House in the mid 80's. Below: A & P Supermarket in the mid 60's.
North Lockwood Ridge Road
6224 - Freddy's Frozen Custard & Steakburgers (since 2015) used to be a KFC Restaurant from about 1994 to 2014.
8415 - Floor & Décor (since 2013) used to be an Albertson's Market from 2000 to 2012.

North Orange Avenue
29 - First Professional Building used to be an A & P Supermarket from about the early-to-mid 40's to 1961.  It was later Kerr's Tradition House furniture store in the mid 60's.
130 - Boca Bargoons (since early 00's) used to be DeSears Appliances from the late 50's for about 40 years.

N Pineapple Avenue
25 - The former Golden Apple Dinner Theater (1971 to 2013) used to be Morrison's Cafeteria in the 1940's until about 1970.
43 - The Pavilion building of the Sarasota Opera House (since 1996) used to be a Montgomery-Roberts department store from at least the 1940's to 1976.
61 - The Sarasota Opera House (opened in January 1984 as The Sarasota Theatre of the Arts) used to be the Florida Theatre (seen below) from 1936 to 1973. It was called Edwards Theater from 1926 to 1936. 

North Tamiami Trail (U.S. 41)
1 - The Vue Condos (since 2016) used to be the location of a Denny's Restaurant from the mid-to-late 80's to early-to-mid 00's (torn down in 2014). It was built as a Ranch House restaurant in the early 70's, becoming Roadway Inn in the 80's and then Indiana Joe's Restaurant in the mid 80's.  The adjacent motel built at the same time was also Ranch House (See below) , and later Palmer House (late 70's) Roadway Inn (early-to-mid 80's) and Holiday Inn Downtown (mid 80's to early 00's) before being torn down.

111 -  This was the site of the John Ringling Towers (opened in 1926 as the El Vernona Hotel).  It was known as John Ringling Hotel until being converted into an apartment complex in 1964, then becoming vacant around the early 80's. Despite major restoration efforts, the building was torn down in 1998 to make way for the Ritz-Carlton Hotel (opened in 2001).  At right: John Ringling Towers
1012 - Sunoco (since the mid 00's) used to be an Imperial Oil service station for over 30 years until about 1983.  It then became Checker Oil, Ecol (mid 80's to mid 90's) and Speedway.  There was also a Dixie Burger Restaurant here from the mid 50's to early 70's.  Below: The Imperial Service Station sign in 1967 along with Dixie Burger Restaurant and Broadway Bar in the background.

1044 - Publix (since 2006) and condominiums were built on the site of the Broadway Bar, which had operated at this location for many, many years (records show as far back as 1925) until 2004.
1777 - Subway Restaurant (since the late 90's) used to be Denner Dogs Restaurant from about 1977 to the mid 90's.
1803 - La Quinta Inn & Suites used to be the location of the Captain's Table Restaurant from to early-to-mid 60's to the mid 70's, when it became the Lanai Restaurant until the mid 80's.  From then until about 1990, it was Far East 41 and then Primo! Restaurant before moving up the street.  It would soon become Wellesley Inn of Sarasota in the early 90's.
2524 - A Shell service station stood in this location for well over 50 years before being torn down in 2007.  Below: A Shell station shown 50 years apart (1956 and 2006) at the intersection of N. Tamiami Tr. and 27th St. (now Dr. Martin Luther King Way).

2808 - Burger King has been at this location since 1966.  The building was torn down and rebuilt in 1981. Before Burger King arrived, Dairy Kreme Ice Cream and Scoop-Burger of Sarasota were here in the 50's and Dutch Treat Restaurant and Tic Toc Restaurant in the first half of the 60's.
2901 - The former Le Anh's Vienamese Restaurant used to be a Pizza Hut Restaurant from 1975 to 2009.  In between, it was Charity Thrift Store.
3020 - A Twistee Treat ice cream stand operated here for about 20 years until the mid 00's.  Below: Twistee Treat

3025 - Carr's Corner Restaurant (since 2002) used to be Mister Sandwich Restaurant from the late 60's to the early-to-mid 80's. It was built in 1958 as Quaker Maid Dinette and shortened to The Dinette in the 60's.  Other businesses here after Mister Sandwich have included Battle's Bar-B-Que (mid 80's), Willybob's Bar-B-Que (mid-to-late 80's), Pinch-A-Penny Pool Supplies(late 80's), Corner Pantry (early 90's), Froggy's Healthy Fast Food (early-to-mid 90's), Gators Grille (opened in 1996) and Chicago Italian Beef Sandwich Co.(opened in 1999).
3333 (10) - The former Good For All Flea Market in the Trail Plaza used to be a Publix Supermarket (see photo) from 1966 to 1996. It then became Community Market until 1997 and a Goodwill Store until moving up the street in 2012.
3500 - Walmart Neighborhood Market (since 2012) used to be a Winn Dixie Supermarket (Kwik Chek until the 70's) from 1957 to 2010.
3709 - CVS Pharmacy (built as Eckerds Pharmacy in 1998) used to be the location that started as 7 Steers Restaurant in the early-to-mid 60's and became Angus Inn Restaurant from 1964 to the early 70's, Garden Gate Restaurant (early 70's) and Adami's Restaurant from the mid-to-late 70's to the late 80's.  Until being torn down, it was also Grapevine Steak & Seafood, Jerry's Airport Catering, Backstreet Pub and G. Willikers.
3728 - Lock Man Locksmith (since the early-to-mid 2010's) used to be Mamma Onesti Italian Restaurant (also called Casa Onesti) from about 1984 to 2005.  It then became Marko's Grill and was later American Kitchen and Pizzeria starting in 2007. Prior to that, restaurants included Pilot Hee (mid 50's), The Lantern (late 50's), Good's Chick-Inn (early 60's), Seven Seas (mid 60's), Cook's Chick-Inn (late 60's), Dawn's Donuts (early 70's) Iron Gate (mid 70's) and Nino's (late 70's to 1984).
4195 - Kasa Sushi Japanese Restaurant (since 2016) used to be a Kentucky Fried Chicken restaurant from 1969 to about the mid 00's.  Since then, it has also been Gold Dynasty and Queen of Sheba restaurants.
4211 - Torn down around 2012, this used to be Mari's House Of Pancakes from about 1962 to the early 70's. It then became Hazel's Restaurant for the rest of the decade.  Earlier, it had been Walker's Restaurant and The Surf in the 50's and Royal Pancake Parlor in the early 60's. Later it was Paragon Music Center in the from the early-to mid 80's to the mid 90's and then Pleasures II.
4675 - The Bahi Hut Lounge, part of the Golden Host Resort Hotel has been here since 1954.
4685 - The Mel-O-Dee Restaurant operated here from 1955 until about the mid 00's.  Below:
Postcard of the Mel-O-Dee restaurant

5050 - Barnacle Bill's Seafood Restaurant & Market (since 2001) used to be the Mecca Restaurant and Supper Club (opened in 1957) and then the Golden Buddah Restaurant from 1968 to the early 90's. It was also the Sai Woo restaurant from 1990 to 2000.  Photo:
Golden Buddah Restaurant
5100 - Goodwill Industries (built in 2012 at 5150 N. Tamiami Tr.) is at the location that was the home of the Old Hickory Restaurant from 1949 to 2005.  It then became Witness Café and was torn down shortly before being rebuilt.
6101 - Now part of New College, this was the location of the popular Zinn's Restaurant for at least 45 years until closing on New Years' Eve 1986.  Below: Zinn's Restaurant

6301 - The Campus Bookshop for USF Sarasota-Manatee & New College used to be a Howard Johnson's Restaurant from about the late 50's to the early-to-mid 80's. It was then the Patti Cake Restaurant in the mid 80's. Photo: Howard Johnson's Restaurant.
8076 (was 7113) - Primo! Ristorante (since 1990) used to be The Golden Buddah Restaurant from the late 50's to the late 60's after earlier being Le Chateau Fine Food. It was later Ruston's Family Affair Restaurant & Steakhouse (early 70's), Beef & Bottle (1972 to 1978), Friar Tucks (1979 to 1980), Rudy Rosa's Organ Grinder Supper Club (early 80's) and People's Restaurant and Lounge (early to mid-to-late 80's).  Below:  Golden Buddah Restaurant at what was then 7113 N. Tamiami Tr.

8154 (was 7007) - Bayside Pet Resort used to be Rip Van Winkle Bowladrome Lanes beginning in 1958 and operating all the way until 2004.  In between, it was BP Group Aviation.
8270 (was 6831) - The Hilton Garden Inn (since late 2001) was built on the site of the Trail Drive-In outdoor movie theater (operated from 1949 to 1988).
8301 - A few of the many hangars offered to businesses by the SRQ Airport now occupy the site of the Three-O-Six Bomb Group restaurant, which operated from 1981 to 1993.

North Tuttle Avenue
2 - Sarasota MRI (originally Dimension Imagining since 2003) used to be the popular House Of Chong restaurant from 1960 until moving to S. Tamiami Trail in 1977. Prior to 1960 and again briefly after in 1978, it was the circus-themed Casa Canestrelli Restraurant.  It was also Charlie's Po Boys Bar-B-Que in the late 70's.  Below: House Of Chong

North Washington Boulevard (U.S. Route 301)
560 - Walt's Plaza (since 2000) used to be the site of Walt's Seafood and Fish Market (pictured below) from the early to mid 70's to 1999.

820 - Popeye's Louisiana Kitchen has been in this location since about the early-to-mid 80's.
918 - Gyros and Seafood (since 2009) used to be a KFC restaurant from about the late 90's to mid 00's.
1000 - Answer America (since early-to-mid 90's) used to be a Lil' General food store (early 70's to 1984), then Circle K (1984 to late 80's). In the late 60's, it was called Three Suns Food Stores.
1068 - Mi Tierra Restaurant (since about the early 00's) used to be Lester's Diner from the early 60's to the early-to-mid 80's when it became John's Diner.  It was also Country Hearth later in the 80's.  In the 90's, it was Subs and More, and then Taco Casa.
1120 - America's Super Pawn used to be Tucker's Exxon Station from the early 70's to mid 80's.  Other businesses here included Electro Bake auto painting (late 80's), Little Fiberglass Shop and American Legend Cycles.
1158 - A small plaza sits today at the site of the popular Oberlin's Diner (shown below) from 1971 to about the early 00's. Prior to Oberlin's it was Russo's Diner beginning about 1963 or 1964.
1199 - This has been an International House of Pancakes (IHOP) restaurant since being built in 1980.
1701 - A Sarasota institution for 60 years, the Hob Nob Drive-In Restaurant opened in March 1957.  The restaurant was closed for a few weeks for renovations in 2013, but still retained its look and feel.  Photo: Hob Nob is seen here in the 1960's.
5445 - Public Storage used to be the Crown House Restaurant (and Duck Inn) from the early-to-mid 70's through the early 90's. Earlier, it was also Holiday House (mid-to-late 50's), Morrison's Imperial House (late 50's to late 60's), Buresh's Lobster House (opened in 1969) and Jerry's Seafood House (early 70's).

Ocean Boulevard (Siesta Key)
5133 - Village Café Restaurant (since 1995) used to be The Buttery Restaurant from the early 70's to mid 90's.
5208 - Big Olaf Creamery (since early-to-mid 80's) used to be both Siesta Key Jewelers (1972 to early 80's) and Siesta Barber Shop (pre-1960 to early-to-mid 80's listed at 5210 Ocean Blvd). Below: Prior to 1982, Siesta Barber Shop and Siesta Key Jewelers shared the space that is now Big Olaf Creamery.
5211 - Beach Bazaar (since mid 80's) used to be Petticoat House clothing store in the 50's until the early-to-mid 80's.
5218 - The former Jo-To Japanese Restaurant (early 00's to 2017) used to be The Wildflower Restaurant from 1974 to 1998.
5250 - Daiquiri Deck (since 1993) used to be Anna's Delicatessen in the 70's and Café Gardens in the 80's and early-to-mid 90's.
Below:Anna's Delicatessen and Café Gardens

Ringling Boulevard
1927 (Charles Ringling Building)  - Sarasota Sky Bar & Club (since 2016) used to be Bifano's Italian Restaurant from about the late 50's to mid 70's.  After a brief time as The Outside Inn, it then became Behind The Turtle Lounge for the rest of the 70's.  The 80's saw Playground South and Animal House until the early 90's when it turned into Club Wave for a short time.  At about 1993, it became Bumper's Nightclub until 1999.  It would then become Margarita Maggie's a few weeks later in 1999 until 2003, turning into Club Envy. It was later The Rhythm Nightclub & Bassline Lounge, The Venue at 1927 and Froggy’s.  This building dates back to 1926 when one of the first tenants was My Name Grocery Store. After many years as Barth's Pure Food Store, it became Sal's Restaurant in 1953.
2257 - Shamrock Pub (since the mid-to-late 90's) used to be Papa Nick's Spaghetti House from the early 60's to the early-to mid70's. Restaurants in between included Mister G's, Margie's, Stingers and The Little Bar in the 70's, Churchill's Inn from the early-to-late 80's and Ringling Street Pub in the first half of the 90's.

St. Armand's Circle (formerly Harding Circle)
411 - Columbia Restaurant has been in this location since 1959, making it Sarasota's longest running restaurant.
420 - Crab & Fin Restaurant used to be known as Charley's Crab Restaurant from the late 70's to about the early 00's.
431 - Café L'Europe Restaurant (since 1973) used to be Colombi's Restaurant until the early 70's.

Sarasota Quay
208 - In Extremis nightclub operated in the Sarasota Quay complex near Fruitville Road in downtown Sarasota from about 1994 to 2003.
318 - Da Ru Ma Japanese Steakhouse operated in the Sarasota Quay complex from 1993 to 2006 before moving to the Sarasota Crossings plaza. The complex was torn in 2007.

Shopping Avenue (Ringling Shopping Center from 1955 to 2017)
170 - The former LTM Party Store (1992 to 2012) used to be a Belk Lindsey department store from 1955 to 1988.
206 - The former Ace Hardware (2005 to 2017) used to be a Woolworth department store from 1955 to early 1994. In between, it was Dockside Imports (opened in 1994).
210 - The former Waffle Shop (from 1992 into the 00's) used to be a Diana Shops dress store from 1955 to about the late 70's.  In between, it was Kuban's audio/video store from the early-to-late 80's.
Below: Diana Shops, Woolworth and Belk-Lindsey stores in the mid 60's.

282 - Publix Supermarket was here from 1955 to 2011, when it moved to a new location on South Tamiami Trail.  At the time it closed, it was the longest operating store in the Publix chain.

South Beneva Road
75 - This was the home of a Rax Roast Beef restaurant in the 80's through 1990. It was later Papa Nick's restaurant before being torn down around late 2007-early 2008.
6980 - Beneva Flowers & Gifts (since 1986) used to be Karl Ehmers Quality Meats II in the early 80's.
6988 - This Sunoco station once sold Bay Gasoline in the late 70's.  It was also a Starvin' Marvin station in the 80's into the 90's, then Speedway until about 2010. 
Photo 1: Although operating under the Speedway banner, this was still a Starvin' Marvin convenience store in 1997. 
Photo 2: The same station in 2008 (no longer Starvin' Marvin) with much higher gas prices!

South Lemon Avenue
35 - Hyde Park Prime Steak House (since 2008) is at the location that used to be King Kone Restaurant from about the mid 60's to early 90's.  It was then rebuilt as Lemon Coast Grill until 1998 and rebuilt again as Ovo Café until 2003.

South Lime Avenue
10 - It wasn't the first 7-Eleven in Sarasota, but it has certainly lasted the longest as the store has been at this same location since about 1961.

South Orange Avenue
220 - Torn down many years ago, this used to be a Piggly Wiggly grocery store in the early 40's before switching to Margaret Ann in 1942 until moving to a new store in 1950.  Later in 1950, it became the first Kane's Furniture store until the early 60's.

South Osprey Avenue
3500 -  The PNC Bank location is where the popular Simple Sam's Market operated from the 50's to the 80's.
3550 -  Shakespeare’s Craft Beer & Gastro Pub, located in what was once known as Simple Sam's Plaza used to be The French Hearth Bakery from the late 70's into the 90's.
3825 - Publix supermarket (since 1996) sits today in the former location of the Azar (later Crossroads) Plaza Rocking Chair Theater, which operated from 1965 to 1991 and was torn down in late 1994.  Photo Crossroads Theater in 1982.

South Tamiami Trail  (U.S. 41)
707 – Sarasota Ford (since 1995) used to be Anderson Ford (1965 to 1981) and Pelican Ford (1981 to 1995).

811 - America's Best Value Inn used to be a Howard Johnson's Motor Lodge (pictured below) that opened in 1966 and operated until about the mid 80's, becoming Sunshine EconoLodge in 1986.  It would then resurface as a Howard Johnson Express Inn about ten years later until the late 00's.

855 - Taco Bell used to be a Howard Johnson restaurant (for over thirty years until 1989). It was also BeMent's Southern Kitchen (1989 to 1993), City Diner, Kenny Rogers’ Roasters and Harvest Rotisserie in the 90’s.
891 - Sarasota Museum of Arts' The Works building used to be Galloway Furniture from 1959 to about 1974.  It would become the Sarasota Optical Center in 1977 and later was Visionworks from about 1990 to 2015.
1155 - Amscot used to be a Royal Castle restaurant (1960 to late 1973 or early 1974). It was then remodeled into a Pan American bank in late 1974.  It later became a Sun Bank in the mid 80's and Optical Value in the mid 90's.  At left: Royal Castle is shown under construction in July 1960. At right: Pan American Bank in the 70's.
1201 - BB&T bank at Midtown Plaza used to be a Sears Auto Center, which was in front of Sears Department Store.  Sears was here from 1960 until moving to Sarasota Square Mall in 1979. At right and below: Sears Department store in the early 1960's at the now Midtown Plaza   
1277 – Panera Bread (since 2010) used to be Bennigan’s Grill &Tavern (1982 to 2010).
1325 – The Midtown Plaza supermarket has been converted from a Grand Union (opened in 1981) to Kash & Karry (1984) to Sweetbay (2005) and finally to Winn Dixie (2014). The original grocery store in the plaza (then known as Sears Shopping Plaza) was opened as a Food Fair in 1958 and later rebranded into Pantry Pride in late 1969 until closing in early 1979.
1339 -  Papa Nicks Spaghetti House was a popular dining spot here in the 50's until about 1958.

1414 – The Satellite Phone Store used to be a Waffle House restaurant (early 70’s to the late 00’s). In between it was Jeff's Salad Company.  Below : Waffle House
1425 - Best Western used to be a Quality Inn along with Martine’s Restaurant (Martine's opened in 1950) until the late 70’s. The Sea Ketch restaurant (1981 to 1985) was also here.
1428 – The Eyes Specialists location used to be a Krispy Kreme donut shop (mid-to-late 60’s until 1973), becoming a dialysis center in the mid-70’s. Many restaurants and businesses on the west side of the trail in the vicinity of Sarasota Memorial Hospital (SMH) would also be turned into or rebuilt as medical centers/practices or acquired by SMH. 
1500 - The former Burger King (1978 until about 2002) sits next to a unit of SMH (Heart and Vascular) and was acquired by and is utilized by the hospital at this time. Prior to Burger King, the property was occupied by the Town House Motel.  At right: Burger King in front of the SMH Heart and Vascular Center in 1998. The restaurant building is now used by SMH.

1540 – The Sarasota Memorial Heart and Vascular location was once the home of the popular Lum’s Restaurant (1969 to 1984), which was known for its hot dogs steamed in beer. At right: It's not too clear, but the Lum's and Burger King signs can be seen side-by-side in 1978.
1575 – BankUnited (since 2014) used to be an Arby’s Roast Beef (late 1969 or early 1970 until 2000), followed by Basil’s and later shared by Firehouse Subs and Dunkin Donuts starting in 2005.
1600 - A uniquely shaped drive-in restaurant called Burger Queen once stood in this location presently utilized by SMH for a building and parking. The restaurant opened in 1959 and operated until 1972. The French-styled Eddy’s Café opened here later that year, continuing for most of the next eight years (changed to a deli in 1979, then back to Eddy’s in 1980). From 1981 and for the remainder of the 80’s, several eateries passed through, including Michael's Place for Ribs, Chatter's Roadhouse, Swenson’s Ice Cream and The Parlour before the property was acquired by SMH.   Below: Eddy's Café in 1973 and Michael's A Place For Ribs in 1981 were among the restaurants that occupied the former Burger Queen space after it was rebuilt in 1972-73.

1601 – The Wendy’s Restaurant currently in this location was built in the early 80’s on the site of the old Floridian Court Motel. 
At right: Wendy's Restaurant at 1601 S. Tamiami Trail in 2006.

1630 – Similar to 1600 S Tamiami Trail, this property was acquired by SMH in the early 90’s. Previously, a Mister Donut had been in this location for about 30 years until 1992.  At right: Mister Donut in the early 1960's.
1635 – Tijuana Flats, which opened in late 2002 was originally a Mr. Gatti’s Pizza (complete with arcade games) built in 1981 and operating until 1988. The location had previously been the home of the Towers Motel. The pizza would later be served up by Pepperoni’s Pizza and Pasta from the late 80’s to early 90’s. In 1992, hot dogs would become the specialty with a Nathan’s Famous restaurant here for a couple of years.  In late 1994, Dunkin Donuts and Miami Subs moved in to share the space and Baskin Robbins Ice Cream was also here.  Below: Mr. Gatti's Pizza in 1981.
1707 – Chipotle Mexican Grill was the location of a McDonald’s restaurant (one of the first in Florida) for about 25 years starting in 1957. It briefly became a Long John Silvers restaurant, then became a Pizza Hut in the mid-80’s for 20 years. Below: 1961 yearbook photo of McDonald's.
1725 - Subway (since late 80's) used to be Herrald’s TV and Sound from the early 70s to late 80’s.  City Paint (late 50's to about 1964), Harris Paint Center (mid 60's) and Maryland Fried Chicken (late 60’s before moving up the street) were here before that.

1737 – The former Square One Burgers (2010 to 2015) used to be the popular Kissin Cuzzins’ restaurant for almost thirty years until July 1999 becoming Sugar Loaf in December and then a few others (Carpe Diem, Sarasota Café., Mel's, Longetivity Café) in the 00’s. From the early-to mid 60's to the late 60's, this was a Perkins Pancake House.  At right: Kissin Cuzzins' Restaurant. Below:
After major renovations to the building, Sugar Loaf Restaurant opened in December 1999 
1850 - This location was known in recent years for being the home of the Sugar and Spice Amish restaurant (1984 to late 1997) before the property was acquired by SMH and the building then torn down. The Dutch Pantry (1959 to early 70’s) was the other longtime occupant of the restaurant. Others in between included Garden Inn (1976 to 1977), Tony Thayer's, TR Murphy’s and Gillespie's. Below: Dutch Pantry and Sugar and Spice

1900 – This Plastic Surgery location housed a Phillips 66 gas station in the 50’s up to about the mid-70’s.
1935 – Goodwill was previously a Gulf service station in the 50’s up to about the late-80’s.
2601 –Center for Sight was constructed on the site of the former Sunnyside Motel. The motel was demolished in 1999 to build the center.
3201 - Sarasota Physicians Surgical Center used to be Donald-Roberts Furniture (shown below) from 1959 to 1962 or 1963.  It then became Top Value Stamps from 1963 to about the mid 70's.

3500 - Chase Bank (since 2015) operates in the location that was occupied by Swiss Chalet Restaurant from 1941 to the late 50's.  Richmond Construction Company was here in the 60's and 70's and physician's offices from the 80's until being torn down in the mid 2010's.
Photo: Swiss Chalet Restaurant
3501 (60- now 1100) - This used to be a Publix Supermarket from 1956 to 1994 (torn down in early 1996) in the Southgate Plaza (now Westfield Siesta Key Mall). Saks Fifth Avenue took over the former Publix space from 1996 to 2014.  CinéBistro Siesta Key Theater moved into this location in 2016.
3501 (82) - This was a Woolworth's Department store in Southgate Plaza from 1956 to early 1994.  It would become Dockside Imports later that year. Photo: Woolworth's in the early-to-mid 60's.
3501 (120) - World Bazaar gifts was at the plaza (originally unit 140) from the early-to-mid 70's to mid-to-late 80's.
3501 (130) - Cloth World was also here from the early-to-mid 70's to mid-to-late 80's.
3501 (200) - The second supermarket at the plaza was Winn Dixie (originally Kwik Check) from 1956 to the mid 80's.
3501 (400) - The former Dillard's (1991 to 2014) used to be a J.C. Penney (aka Penney's) Department Store from 1961 to 1977.  It then became Robinson's in 1978 before converting to Maison Blanche in 1987.  In 2017, it was announced that Lucky's Market would be taking over at least part of Dillard's space in the mall (opened in October 2017) along with LA Fitness (since 2016).
3501 (600) - Macy's Department Store (since 2005) in the Westfield Siesta Key Mall used to be a W.T. Grant Department Store from 1972 to 1975 (was previously in unit 120 from 1956 to 1972 before a remodel). It then became Burdine's Department Store from 1976 to 2005.

3501 (950) - Torn down in 1997, this was the site of the popular Brown Derby Restaurant (was briefly called Kapio's in 1989) in the Southgate Plaza (now Westfield Siesta Key Mall) from 1979 to 1994 before becoming Cahill's.  Prior to Brown Derby, it was Morrison's Cafeteria from about 1962 to 1977.  At right: Brown Derby in 1990.  Below: Morrison's Cafeteria (mid 60's) and Brown Derby Restaurant (early 80's)

3800 (21) - The area Pier 1 Imports (since 2015)  now occupies (at least some of it along with CVS) in the Paradise Plaza (formerly Crossroads and earlier Azar) was once an A & P Supermarket.  A & P was in this plaza from 1959 to late 1978 and replaced by a Great Scot supermarket (1979-81), then Mister C's Warehouse.  A Phar-Mor store opened here in the mid-80's and operated until 2002.  Pier 1 replaced Borders Books (2004 to 2011).
3800 (26) - Gigi's Italian Restaurant was located at the Crossroads (now Paradise) Plaza from 1975 until the early-to-mid 80's.
3800 (33) - The Sawmill Inn was here in the Crossroads (now Paradise) Plaza from the mid 70's to early 1989.  It then became the Backstreet restaurant.  At right: Sawmill Inn

3825 - Johnny's Car Wash has been in this location since about the late 50's. It was briefly listed as South Gate Auto Service. At left: Johnny's Car Wash around the mid 60's
3875 - McDonald's was built on the site previously occupied by Boston Market (briefly Boston Chicken) restaurant from 1993 to 2009.  From 1960 to the early 90's this location was a bank (Sarasota Federal Savings until the early 70's, then Coast Savings). Even earlier from the mid-to-late 50's, it was Gulf Cities Gas Corp. Below:
Boston Market in 2007.

3880 - This used to be a Shakey's Pizza restaurant in the late 60's and early 70's.  A USN Recruiting office along with several other recruiting offices operated at about this location from the mid 70's to mid 80's.
3902 - Valvoline Instant Oil Change (since 2013) used to be the Trail Union 76 service station from the early 70's to the early 90's. It was also Florida Car Care Center and then Mobil 1 Lube Express (mid 90's to 2013).
3904 - Mattress Firm used to be a restaurant/lounge, including Shannon's Way (1977-1983), Impressions of Sarasota, 1776 Restaurant (1985-1992), Stockyard Steakhouse, Banana's Bar & Grill and Notorious.  By 2000, it became a Ritz Camera and Boater's World store. Below: The upper façade of the 1776 Restaurant in 1986.

3908 - Supercuts (since early 90's) used to be Jay's Shoes (early 1978 to 1983). In between, it was First American Title.   At right: In 1978, Jay's Shoes, Super Value Drugs and Shannon's Way Pub shared the small plaza that still sits just south of the Bee Ridge Rd./So. Tamiami Tr. intersection.
3909 - Torn down in 1998 to make way for Walgreens, this used to be Dixie Lee's Liquors from the late 40's until the mid-to-late 80's before moving just around the corner (to 2030 Bee Ridge Rd until 1997).  It then became O'Lyn Callahan's Yamaha Music Center and later Classic Keyboard in the mid 90's.  At right:
Dixie Lee Liquors at 3909 S. Tamiami Tr., referred to as "3909 Boondoggle Blvd" by Dixie Lee due to never-ending construction for road widening that limited the access to the building.

3935 -Located at about where Sir Speedy Printing is today, this used to be A's Giant Sandwiches from the mid 60's until moving to its present location at 6300 S. Tamiami Tr. in the early 80's. In then became Two Guys From Italy Deli for a short time.  Originally, this was Jules Army-Navy Surplus store (with a rocket sign out front) from late 1958 to the early 60's.
3971 - Bonefish Grill (since 2001) used to be an Applebee's restaurant from 1990 to 2000.
3979 - Diamond Vault (since 2011) used to be Peaches Music (late 1989 to 1995), then West Marine from 1995 to 2010 before moving down the street.

4000 - IHOP restaurant used to be a Village Inn Restaurant (1977 to 2008).  This was also the address of Snelling Plaza from 1976 to 1995, and before that, it was a Montgomery Ward department store from 1965 to 1976. At left: Village Inn in 2007.  At right: Montgomery Ward sign in 1973.

4001 -  Café Baci Restaurant (since 1991) used to be a Western Sizzlin' Restaurant from the early 70's to 1990. Below: Western Sizzlin' in 1989 and Café Baci at the same location in 2011

4023 - Verizon  (since 2015) occupies the area that was the home of the very popular El Adobe Mexican Restaurant from 1974 to 2014.  Other restaurants here included Blake's (mid 50's), Burger King (1957 to early 60's), Little Pig's House (early-to-mid 60's), Trail B-B-Q (mid 60's), Beef Pit (mid-to late 60's), Gordon's Diner (late 60's) and Romano's Italian Restaurant (1970 to 1974).  Below:  El Adobe Restaurant sign in the 80's and in 2014.

4034 - Now an empty lot in front of Best Buy, this was the site of a Steak and Ale restaurant from the late 70's to 2007.
4035 - The former Puppy Town used to be the Self Service Shoe from the late 50's until the early 90's.  It then became Great Deals on Heels from 1991 until 1993 and then Futons Etc. for about a decade.  Below: Self Service Shoe Store sign in 1989 and Great Deals on Heels store in 1992.

4065 - Lox and Egg (since 2006) used to be a Burger King from about 1968 to 1978.  It turned into Buning the Florist from 1979 to 1987, then Sub Conscious sandwich shop (1987 to about 1993) and Manhattan Bagel (mid 90's-2006).  Below: Great photo from early 1974 where Burger King (now Lox and Egg) can be seen on the left along with several long lost businesses that were located at about the area where Trader Joe's operates today. These include: Vel-von Paint Center, Butler TV, Double Knit Factory Outlet (shown having a going out of business sale before the store closed in 2/74) and Discount Tire Center (later H & H Hobby Sales from the late 70's to early 90's).
4101 - Trader Joe's (since 2012) was a Rooms To Go furniture store from the mid 90's until moving up the street in 2011.
4123 - Now used for parking, this used to be a Pay-Less Service Station (at left) from the early 70's until the mid 80's before being torn down in 1986.  Earlier, it was an Empire Service Station from about 1957 to 1962 and a Kayo Service Station from 1963 to the early 70's.
4130 - T-Mobile operates in an area once occupied by the All Night Chevron station (at right) in the 80's and a Standard station in the 60's and 70's.
4131 - Chili's Restaurant was built in 1986 at the location that used to be the Trail-Vu Motel from the mid 50's to 1984.
4144 -  Walt's Fish Market (since 1977) used to be a Burger Chef restaurant from about the late 60's to 1974. In between it was Wilcox House of Music. Below: Walt's Fish Market in 1989 next to the sign for the above-mentioned Chevron station.
4200 - Mattress One (at 4238 S. Tamiami) occupies the area that was the home of the Fashion Door store from 1978 until the early-to-mid 90's and then became The Christmas Shoppee.  In the early-to-late 70's, it was Mort's Sportsman Cove and later Castro Convertibles. Even prior to that in the 60's, a Sunoco station was here.  Below: The Fashion Door in 1978.

4227 - Dinettes Unlimited (since 1976) had previously been Furniture Warehouse earlier in the 70's.
4231 - Ace Hardware used to be a Masters Catalog Showroom from the early 70's to about 1984, then Midtown Hardware's Home Basics from the mid 80's to early 00's.
4250 - A small plaza now occupies the area where a Tastee-Freez ice cream stand stood for nearly 25 years until about 1983.  It had been moved from 1838 South Tamiami Trail in the late 50's. Below:
Tastee-Freez in the 1960's.

4333 - King James men's fashions (since 1993) used to be BeMent's Chicken Restaurant (later known as BeMent's Country Boy) known for their broasted chicken from shortly before 1960 until 1983. It had been Harbor Oaks Restaurant in the 50's. In between BeMents and King James,, it was Frankie C's and Hooter restaurants as well as Greatland Gold & Diamond and Bodywrap Int.. Below:
BeMent's Chicken from a 1960's postcard and later in 1978 as BeMent's Country Boy Restaurant.

4407 - Giggles (since 1997) used to be Katy's Kloset dress shop from the mid-70's to late 80's. In between, it was Mimi's Petite Boutique.
4410 - Demetrio's Restaurant & Pizza opened in early 1975 and is still here after over 40 years. Below: Demetrio's in 1975.

4413 - Taste Of Asia restaurant (since 2013) used to be a Wendy's restaurant from 1976 to the late 90's, followed by Shang Hai Express from the late 90's to about 2007.
4420 - Shelly's Gifts and Christmas Boutique (since 2016) occupies the property which held both a Blimpie sandwich shop and Rita's Italian Ice store from 1999 to about 2006. although the Blimpie and faded Rita's signs still stood for several years after the building was torn down (see below).  Among the other businesses at this location was a Gulf service station from the 1960's to about 1980 and Allied Tires from the early to late 80's. Below: A Blimpie/Rita's Ad from the store opening in July 1999, the store in 2007 after it had closed, and the sign out front that stood until 2015, several years after the building had been torn down.

4450 - Marlin's Raw Superfood For Pets (since 2017) used to be the Hong Kong Kitchen restaurant from 1972 to the early 90's. In the 1950's until about 1967, the Big Mug root beer stand (4440 South Tamiami) was in this location.  After Hong Kong Kitchen, it was Sarasota Medical Center from 1994 to 2017 before moving to Bee Ridge Rd.

4500 - Florida Surgical Supply (since the mid-00's) was built as a Maryland Fried Chicken restaurant (1969 to 1973),  somehow turning into Tamiami Adult Books (mid 70's), but is most known for its time as the popular Camel's Den restaurant (1978 to 1993).   Other restaurants here included Villa Capri (1994-late 90's), International House of Curries and Yanni's Greek Tavern (2001-mid 00's). Below: Camel's Den Restaurant in 1978 and the same building as Florida Surgical Supply over 30 years later.

4520 - Alpine Steakhouse (since early 90's) used to be the China Inn restaurant (1971 to 1978) and Rose Garden restaurant (1978 to 1985). Earlier, it was Topper's Steak House (1968 to 1969) and Trail Hickory Bar-B-Q (1969-1970).  In the mid-to-late 80's, Capone's Pizza and Crab Company restaurant were here.  Below: China Inn in 1972  The Enco station on the left is Al Fige's Servicenter.
4608 - G. Fried Flooring (since 1973) used to be the location of the Chiropractic Health Center from the late 50's through the 60's. It was also Portrait Pools in the early 70's before being rebuilt.
4613 - Torn down in 2015, this used to be Wilson's Texaco (later Spur) from the 50's to about the late 80's). The building was restored with Texaco pumps as Studio 41 gallery in the late 90'sBelow:
Although it had closed by the time this photo was taken in the mid-90's, Wilson's Spur Service Station (formerly Texaco) and its gas pumps were still standing at 4613 S. Tamami Trail before being restored a few years later.

 4650 - Ashley HomeStore (since 2015) used to be Haverty's Furniture from late 1969 to early 2001 before moving up the street. In between, it was DeSears Appliances from 2002 to 2009, then reopened from 2011 to 2014. Below: Haverty's Furniture at its prior location at 4650 S. Tamiami Tr.
4675 - Sarasota Classified/Teachers' Association (SCTA) used to be The Bedspread and Drapery Shop from 1973 to the early 90's.  In between, it was Child Berth children's furniture store from the early-to-mid 90's.  At right: The Bedspread and Drapery Shop in the mid 80's.
4708 - West Marine (since 2010) used to be a Circuit City electronics store from about 1992 to 2010. At left: Circuit City shortly before closing in 2010.

4730 - This building that now houses multiple stores (Subway, Zoom Tan, Great Clips, Tuesday Morning) used to be a Bookstop bookstore from 1992 to 1996.  It then became split between a Blockbuster Video store (1997 to 2010). and Pier One Imports (1997 to 2015). At right: Bookstop in 1996.
4831 - A Mr. Steak Restaurant was here from 1969 to 1974, followed by Uppy's Family Restaurant for about a couple of years starting in January 1975. The Manatee Public Library Digital Collection website has a great photo of the restaurant as Mr. Steak.
4840 - Publix Supermarket (since early 2009) in the Landings Plaza used to be an Albertsons Market from 1988 to 2008.
Photo:Albertsons (now Publix) at The Landings Plaza
4850 -  This used to be a Radio Shack store in the Landings Plaza from about 1989 to early 2015. Below: Radio Shack closing sale at The Landings Plaza in February 2015.
4871 - Sherwin-Williams Paints (since 1978) used to be Babcock Furniture from 1969 to the mid 70's. In between, it was H & H Hobby Sales.
4934 - Jo-Ann Fabrics (since 1997) in the Landings Plaza used to be a Discovery Zone (DZ) children's play center from late 1993 to late 1996.  Earlier it was Cloth World from 1988 to 1993.
4940 - The former Office Depot (early 90's to 2015) in the Landings Plaza used to be a Lechmere electronics and appliance store (1987-1989). Photo: Lechmere just before closing its Florida stores including this one at the Landings in 1989.
4994 - Sweet Tomatoes restaurant (since 1996) used to be a Casa Lupita restaurant that opened in 1985 and became Casa Amigos in 1990.
5170 - Rooms To Go (since 2011) used to be Darby Buick from about 1966 to 2006.
5251 - Leather Gallery and Bedding Center (since 2014) used to be a Radio Shack Computer Center from 1982 to the early 90's. Ethan Allen Design Center was also here from 2008 to early 2014.

5252 - The former Kane's Furniture (Kalin's since 2013) was here from February 1968 to 2016. Hollyhurst Motel was in this location previously until the mid 60's. At right: Kane's Furniture in 1968.
5365 - The Table Creekside Restaurant used to be Abbey's Oyster Bar in the 80''s and first part of the 90's
5778 - Joe-Lin Lampshades (since 1987) used to be Barton's Corner Sundries and then Swede's Sundries from the mid 50's to mid 60's. It was later Ellen Swope School Of Dancing (late 60's), Scandia Construction (early 70's), Brownies Pool Clinic (early 70's to early-to-mid 80's) and Echo clothing (mid 80's)
5900 - Now the site of a plaza (opened in 1986 as DeSears Plaza), this used to be the site of the Star Lite Restaurant from 1954 to the late 70's. It was also known as Uncle Otey's Star Lite Pancake & Steak House beginning in the mid 60's.  The restaurant was accompanied by a service station (Phillips 66, then Esso-Enco) until the early 70's, when it became Flowers by Otey.
6018 - Economy Tackle has been here (address was 6024 So. Tamiami until 1962) since 1948.
6024 - Now a four-unit retail building, this used to be Chick-n-Treat Restaurant from 1965 until 1967 and then was Pizza Shanty in 1968 and 1969.  In the 70's, this was a real estate office before becoming The Video Connection in the early 80's. It then became The Wallpaper Store and later Stereorama from 1988 and through the 90's.
6050 - A to Z Autos was built in 1955 as Carlisle Service Station.  After a few changes, it became Royal Tire from 1964 to 1969 and South Trail Tire from 1969 to about the mid 90's.  It would then become Don Olson Tire and later was a GCR Tire Center.  Photo: South Trail Tire sold Phillips 66 gasoline here in the early 70's.  Smith Auto Sales and Economy Tackle (still there today) can be seen in the background.

6112 - The Oaks B-B-Q restaurant (since 1989) was occupied by many different businesses from 1973 to 1989 including Mitchell Black Top Co, Madam Christine Palm Reading, El Conquistador Health Club, Accent Music and Pleasure Pub.
6115 - Before being torn down and rebuilt into a small strip mall, this used to be a Pizza Hut from the early 70's to the early-to-mid 00's.  It was also Wireless Giant in the mid 00's.
Photo: Wireless Giant (former Pizza Hut) can be seen from the 7-Eleven across the street in 2006.

6123 - The former Subway (mid 00's to 2016) used to be a Mister Donut (1972 to about 1993) and Dunkin' Donuts (1993 to 2002).  Below: Dunkin' Donuts and Baskin Robbins in 2002.

6125 - Pho 101 (since 2015) used to be a Lum's restaurant (from 1971 to about 1984) and Mrs. Chens Chinese restaurant (1993 to 2015). In between, the names included Baxter's, Abshires, Café Seville, Giorgio's and Spiro's. At right: Subway and Mrs. Chen's Restaurants.
6131 - New Dynasty Chinese Restaurant (since 1998) used to be a Ponderosa restaurant from the mid 70's until about 1997.
6240 - The former Square 1 Burgers (2015 to 2017) used to be the Li'l Villa Italian American restaurant from about 1971 to 1987.  Prior to that, it was Jerry's Restaurant from at least the mid 50's to the early 70's and later Mario's Restaurant in the late 80's and 90's, J.B.’s,.Ref’s Sportsgrille and Sarah's.
6285 - Dunkin Donuts (since 2015) used to be a Burger King from about 1984 to late 2013. A service station owned by Tropic Oil had been here in the 1960's through the early 80's featuring brands such as Phillips 66 and Bay.  Also here during that time from about 1974 to the early 80's was a restaurant (Zip'z Ice Cream, Jim's Café and then Dutch Valley).
6300 (1) - A's Giant Sandwiches has been in this location since the early 80's. Courtney's Cleaners may have been here in the mid-to-late 70's.
6307 - Gordon Food Service (since 2014) was the location of Sound Advice from 1987 to 2008 (torn down in 2014).  Also here in the 70's to late 1986 or early 1987 was Crown Liquors (listed at 2020 Jo-Ann Drive). Below: Crown Liquors in the 80's and Sound Advice in the 00's.

6320 - Torn down around 2010, this used to be the location of an Empire Service Station from 1963 to 1984.  Safelite Auto Glass was later here (mid 80's through the 90's) as well as Leather Gallery. Seen in the background of the below photo is Rattan Village Furniture.

6331 - SMH Urgent Care at Stickney Point (since 2011) used to be a Sambo's restaurant (mid 70's to late 1982) with a name change to Season's Friendly Eating until 1984.  Restaurants here between 1984 and the change to a health care facility include Village Inn (mid 80's to1990), Farmer's Country Kitchen (1991 to mid 90's), Half Baked Café, Tropical Shores Café, Demetrio's, Fish Tales and Petrella Bros.
6338 - Built in 1972 as Rattan Village, this furniture store would be known as Florida Patio & Rattan during the first half of the 80's.  It then became TV & Appliance World in 1985 and Rex Appliances from the early 90's to 1999.  Before being torn down around 2010, it was Appliance Depot & More from the early-to-mid 00's and temporary quarters for Furniture Warehouse in 2007 and 2008.
6347 - McDonald's opened its second Sarasota location here in 1970 (13 years after the first location was built) and it is still operating today. At right: McDonald's and a Citgo station at 6345 S. Tamiami Tr.(later a McDonald's Playground in the 90's and now Florida Underwater Sports) can be seen from about the mid 70's.
6449 - Eager Beaver Car Wash (since 1977) used to be a used car lot (mainly Reynolds & Sons) from the late 60's to 1976.   Below: Early photo of Eager Beaver Car Wash sign when it sold Exxon gasoline:
6499 - Torn down in early 1995 to make way for Walgreens, this used to be Marty's Service Station (Sinclair until the late 60's) from 1959 to the about 1973, when it became Suncoast Oil of Sarasota and then Gulf Gate Fina.  From 1984 to 1995, it was Economy Auto Rental. Before the service station was built, Via's Bar was at this location from the 1940's until moving next door to 2027 Stickney Point, where (as The Crazy Fox, earlier had changed name to Golden Anchor from 1986 to 1990) it would operate until the same time in 1995.
6501 - The Sarasota Pavilion shopping plaza (formerly Gulf Gate Mall) location once housed the Siesta Drive-In Theater from late 1952 to 1960.
6501 - SunTrust Bank used to be Coast Federal Savings & Loan (also Coast Bank) from the early 70's to about 1993.
6502 - Before being torn down to make way for a turn lane off of Stickney Point Road in the mid-to-late 90's, this was primarily the home of a Royal Castle restaurant (1960 to late 1973 or early 1974) and the original home of The Oaks B-B-Q restaurant from the late 70's to 1989. It was also Cross Roads drive-in restaurant before 1960.
6503 (10) - This used to be Terry Shulman's Discount Health and Beauty Aids store at the Gulf Gate Mall from 1987 to early 1995.  Previously, it had been a Walgreens Liquor Store from the mid 70's to 1987.
6503 (20) - This location at the Gulf Gate Mall next to Publix started as a Sarasota Federal Savings & Loan from the mid 60's to early 70's, followed by Book Corner in the early 70's,  It then became Mrs. O'Leary's Lounge around 1973 or 1974 until the mid-to-late 80's.  From the late 80's until moving to a new location during the conversion to the Sarasota Pavilion in 2000, it was a Hooters Restaurant.
6503 (25) - This location at the Gulf Gate Mall started as a Walgreens Pharmacy from the 1965 to the early-to-mid 90's, followed by Books-A-Million from 1994 until moving to a new location during the conversion to the Sarasota Pavilion in 2000.  Below: Walgreens in 1965

6503 (200) - Gulf Gate Cinema 1 & 2 opened in June 1971 and operated until the Gulf Gate Cinema 8 theatre was built after a renovation to the mall in 1987.  The cinema closed in November 1997.
6503 (415) - Opus Fashions was here at the Gulf Gate Mall from the late 80's until 1996.
6508 - Splash Sun & Fun used to be a Gateway Country computer store from 1999 to 2004.  A service station was in this area in the 60's and early 70's followed by Milex Precision Auto Tune-Up and Interstate Transmissions (late 70's to mid 90's).
6522 - Before Sea Oats Plaza was built in the early 80's, Johnny Nicholas Restaurant was here from the late 50's to around 1974.  Before that, it was the Patio Restaurant.
6535 - Stein Mart department store (since 1994) used to be a Belk Lindsey department store from 1967 to 1994. This building remained as is during the conversion of the Gulf Gate Mall to the Sarasota Pavilion in the late 90's. Below: Belk-Lindsey in the early-to-mid 70's.
6606 - Gecko's Grill & Pub (2017) used to be a Denny's Restaurant (built on the old Siesta Villa Motel site) from the mid 80's to the mid 90's. It later became Water Grill, TP Hans, Friendly's Restaurant (2003 to 2005), Big Al's, Legacy, Bogey's and Harry's Sports Bar & Grill (2013 to 2017).
6700 - Ruth's Chris Steakhouse (since 2000) was the location of the Windjammer/Davey Jones Locker restaurant from 1969 to the mid-to-late 80's and Cook's restaurant before that in the 60's.  From 1989 to the late 90's, it was a car dealership (Mazda of Sarasota). Below:
Cook's and Windjammer Restaurants both at 6700 S, Tamiami Trail.

6727 - Dutch Valley restaurant (in this location since about 1982 after moving from 6285 S. Tamiami Tr.) used to be a Ranch House restaurant (early 70's to early 80's).  Below:
Ranch House Restaurant (now Dutch Valley).

6728 - Dan's Fan City (since 1989) used to be Chappie's Carpet and Floors from the late 60's to mid-to-late 80's. Prior to that, it was Paul's Garden Store.
6731 - This was where a Jerry Lewis Cinema opened in July 1972 (see below), becoming the South Trail Cinema in 1973 until 1993 (and making the news in 1991).  A Kenny Rogers Roasters Restaurant was then built here, but would become Manhattan Bar & Grill shortly after in the mid 90's. for close to 15 years, later becoming Beckham's.   At right: Jerry Lewis Cinema shortly before opening in July 1972. 
6747 - Red Lobster Restaurant opened in December 1970 and is still here over 46 years later. At left: Red Lobster in December 1970.

6914 - This location used to be the House of Chong Restaurant (1977 to 1993) and then Homestyle Harmony (1994 - late 1997 or early 1998) complete with singing waiters and waitresses.
6969 - Tammie's Patio used to be Arthur Treacher's Fish & Chips (1977 to 1981). It was also La Magurita, Leo's Steak and Seafood, Perfectly Frank (hot dogs were on the menu, of course), Suncoast Citrus (late 80's to early 00's), 6969 Design Guild and Underground Auto Styling.
7110 - Ed Howard Lincoln-Mercury used to be Sarasota Lincoln-Mercury from 1978 to 1982. This had previously been the site of the Fountain Court Motel.

7113 - The Devyn Event Venue (since 2014) used to be Sam Seltzer's Steakhouse from early 2000 to 2010 and Livingston's Billiards/Rack & Roll Café prior to that . Also here at 7111 S. Tamiami were: Dover House Restaurant (mid-to-late 70's to early 80's), Adami's Restaurant (1981 to 1988), Pastel's, Jim's Steak House, Box Seat Bar and Grill, Sarasota Grill, Alfred E. Gators and Livingston's until moving in 2005. At right: Adami's Restaurant sign in 1981.
7119 (J) - Fish Market & Grill (since 2016) in Buccaneer Plaza used to be Better Bagels from about 1985 to 1996.  It then became Gastronomia Restaurant from 1996 to 1999 and Figaro's Pasta & Wine Bar at the start of year 2000. It was later G's Pizza & Wings.
7119 (L) - H Built Computers (since 2008, 2006 in this plaza) was originally a Carvel Ice Cream Store from the mid-to-late 80's.  It has also been Penn Treaty Insurance, Charad of Sarasota and Access USA.
7129 - The former SweetFrog used to be a Taco Bell (1982 to about 1996), followed by Taste of Tokyo restaurant and Amalfi's restaurant. Below: Taco Bell in 1982.
7204 - Personalized Fitness & Massage (since 1993) in Willow Oaks Shopping Center used to be Funtime Fashions from the late 60's to the early 90's.
7207 - Outback Steakhouse (since 1989) used to be a Texas Bill's restaurant (1982 to 1983) and Po Folks' Family Restaurant (1984 to 1987 or 88) before the original building was torn down and Outback was rebuilt in 2009.
7221 - AMF Gulf Gate Lanes was called Galaxy Lanes when it opened in 1976 and for the next couple of decades.  It also featured the Astro Lounge.
7241 – Goodwill (since 1988) used to be Midway Groves fruit store (1975 to 1988). 
7253 - The Grasshopper Mexican Restaurant & Bar (since 2013) used to be the popular Shell's Seafood Restaurant (1986 to 2008).  In between, it was Stingray's and then Schuck's. Before Shell's from 1973 to 1985, the names of the restaurant included Bruno's Italian Restaurant, Genaro's Italian Restaurant, Villa Del  Roma, Bavarian Lion and La Marsala.
7250 - Culver's Restaurant (since 2015) was built on the location that was the long time home of The Original Oyster Bar restaurant (pictured below) from 1961 to 2006 .

7275 – Mattison's Forty-One Restaurant & Catering (since 2007) used to be Lone Star Steakhouse (mid 90's to 2007). Other restaurants here included Black Angus (early to mid 70’s), Watermill (mid 70’s) and Grape Vine (1976 to 1982). At left: Grape Vine Restaurant.  At right.  Lone Star Steakhouse sign in 1995.
7321 - Wilde Jaquar of Sarasota (since 1997) was the site of a Steak 'n Shake restaurant (with curbside service) from the mid 70's until late 1986 or early 1987.  Other restaurants here between 1987 and 1997 after being rebuilt included Lacey's, Tassotis Restaurant Italiano (opened in 1988), Tenderloins and Texas Roadhouse.

7322 - The former Driving Expressions (1990 to 2015) used to be a convenience store (Short Stop in the early-to-mid 70's, Speedee Shop in the mid 70's and Farm Stores in the late 70's to early-to-mid 80's.  It was then The Garage Sale store in the mid 80's and Whitesides Appliances in the late 80's). Photo:
Driving Expressions in 1990.
7447 - Geier's Sausage Kitchen (since 1982) used to be the location for Par-T Miniature Golf & Game Room in the late 70's and early 80's.
7500 - Now a small plaza built in 2005 that includes Innovative Design Solutions, this used to be the home of the International King's Table Restaurant in the late 60's until about 1973 when it was then known as King's Bounty Restaurant. In the mid 70's, it became The Cajun Club until the early 80's, then Sarasota Fish Company, Robin & Joel's Restaurant, Woody's BB-Q (1994 to 1997) and La Champagne Restaurant from 1998 to the early-to-mid 00's. Photo: Postcard of International King's Table Restaurant

7690 - Hughes Exterminators (since about 2011) used to be a Self Service Shoe Store from 1975 to 1990 and National Shoe Liquidators until 1991. In between, it was House Of Golf and Pro Golf. Below: Self Service Shoe Store Grand Opening in 1975

8195 - Hobby Lobby (since 2013) used to be a Kmart department store from 1979 to 2008.
8197 - Pizza Hut (since 2003 or 2004) used to be Café LaChaumiere restaurant (pictured below) from 1979 to 1987. It was also Whisper Inn from 1988 to late 1993 or early 1994 and then Rick's Café.

8199 - Staples (since the mid 90's) used to be a Grand Union supermarket (1979-1984) before converting into Kash N 1984 and remained until a nearby store opened in Pelican Plaza in 1988. It was also a Workplace office supplies store in the early to mid 90's.  At right: Grand Union in 1979. Below: Workplace (now Staples) in 1991.

8201 - Macy's at Westfield Sarasota Square Mall (2005 to 2017) used to be a Maas Brothers department store from the mall's opening in 1977 to 1991 before becoming Burdines and eventually Macy's after a short time as Burdines-Macy's.
8201 - J.C. Penney became the mall's second anchor just after the mall's opening in 1977 and was still there 40 years later.
8201 - Sears Department Store opened in October 1979 as the mall's third anchor (along with Mass Brothers and JC Penney) after moving from what is now known as Midtown Plaza.  The store was slated to close in 2017.
8201 - Costco at Westfield Sarasota Square Mall (since 2012) replaced Dillard's (1996 to late 2009) as the mall's fourth anchor.  Dillard's had replaced Parisian (1989 to early 1996). 
8201 (25a) - At about the current location of Old Navy in the mall used to be Morrison's Cafeteria from 1977 to 1999, when it became Piccadilly Cafeteria.
8201 (52) - The former Revive Salon in the mall used to be Mr. Dunderbak's German Restaurant from about 1978 to 1988.  It then became The Wunderbar Restaurant.  It has also been Trade Secret.
8372 - The former Sports Authority in Pelican Plaza (2014 to 2016) used to be a SuperX supermarket from 1983 until converting to Florida Choice until 1988.  It then became a Kash N Karry supermarket from 1988 to 1994 and Linens N Things shortly after until 2008.
Photo: SuperX at Pelican Plaza in 1983Below:  Last days for Linens'N'Things in 2008 and Sports Authority in 2016.
8389 - Built as a Boston Market in the early to mid 90's, this became J.Ryan's in early 1997 to 2014 (was Sammy Frog's for a few months in 2003).  It was later Southside Grill and The Coral House.
8599 – Haverty’s Furniture (since 2001) used to be a Phar-Mor (1991 to 1993), then Roberd’s Furniture (1994 to 2000).

South Tuttle Avenue
3650 - The very popular Tas-T-O Donuts operated here in a small trailer in the Bee Ridge Shopping Center (now Tuttle Bee Plaza) from about 1970 to 1999.
3660 - Dollar Tree used to be Frank's Nursery & Crafts from the early 90's to late 2004 or early 2005. 
3680 - Office Max (since 1993) used to be part of the Zayre/Ames department store (see below) from 1969 to 1990.
3700 - TJ Maxx (since 1991) was a Zayre department store from 1969 to 1988, then converted to Ames from 1988 to 1990.  Below: Zayre department store in 1969.

3750 - The former Beall's Outlet (1990 to 2013) used to be SuperX Drugs from 1969 to the mid 80's. It then became a Rite Aid drug store until 1990. The store was also used as a temporary home for DeSears Appliances before closing its doors for good in 2016.
3810 - YouFit used to be a Kash N'Karry Supermarket from 1969 to 1993.  It later became Recreational Factory Warehouse in 1999 and Atlanta Fitness.
3824 - Dunkin Donuts (since 2015) was built at the location that used to be The Clubhouse Lounge from about the mid-to-late 80's to late 2009 and then becoming The Rusty Hook Tavern before being torn down in 2014.  Earlier business establishments here included Gary's Lounge and Package Store (early-to-mid 70's), Inn Place Lounge (mid 70's) and Shell City Liquors and Lounge (mid-to-late 70's to early-to-mid 80's).
3854 - Tasty Home Cookin' Restaurant used to be The Three Dutchman Restaurant from the early 70's to the mid-to-late 80's.  It later became Milano's Restaurant around 1990.

South Washington Boulevard
110 - The area now used for parking, this used to be a Margaret Ann (later converted to Kwik Chek) grocery store from 1950 to 1969.
239 - Also now used for parking, this used to be the location of Land O'Sun Dairy (see below) from at least the 1940's until the mid 70's.
300 - PPG Paints used to be Porter Paints for about 60 years before being rebranded (as were all stores in the chain) in 2016. Previously in the early 50's, Hollywood Beauty Shop was at this location.

317 - This used to be an A & W Root Beer Restaurant from about the mid 50's to mid 60's. It then became Mr. Pizza Restaurant (also see 323 below) until the mid 70's (known as Mr. Nikla's by that time).
323 - A contractor's office, real estate office, insurance office and Gourmet Pantry Restaurant were among the businesses here from the mid 50's to the late 60's when it became the dining room for Mr. Pizza (later Mr. Nikla's) until the mid 70's.  From the mid 70's to late 70's, it became Rose's Game Room and then Nashville South restaurant & lounge.  It would then become Beck's Place restaurant & lounge until about the late 80's before turning into Score Board restaurant & lounge until being torn down by the late 00's.
500 -   A large office complex sits next to the area where a very popular walk-up Dairy Queen (pictured below) operated from the late 50's until July 30, 2006. 

526 - The office complex mentioned above now occupies the area that used to be McKown's Food Market from the late 40's to the late 70's.  It then became Sarasota Beauty School in the early 80's (until the early-to-mid 90's), Casa del Sol Mexican Art Furnishings in 1997 and Personalized Fitness in about 2002.
544 - American Momentum Bank used to be The Nautilus Shell Shop (see photo) from at least the early 50's to the mid-to-late 60's before becoming Montville's Appliances from the late 60's to mid 70's.  It was then turned into a restaurant (Anthony's and later Alexander's) before converting to a bank (Central National) in the mid 80's. It later became Liberty Savings Bank in the mid-to-late 90's and Landmark Bank in 2003.
660 - Waffle Stop used to be Waffle Shop from about 1953 to 1992 before moving to the Ringling Shopping Plaza. The restaurant is still famous for being the breakfast stop of Elvis Presley in February 1956, while he was in town performing at the Florida Theater.

State Street
1525 - State of the Arts Gallery (since the mid 00's) used to be Draper's Western World from 1954 all the way until moving to Clark Rd. in 2003.

Stickney Point Road
1200 - Captain Curt's Crab and Oyster Bar (since the early-to-mid 80's) used to be Ben's Pizza Café in the late 70's and Brigadoon Restaurant in the early 80's.

1536 - Siesta Key Parasail & Jet Ski used to be Lighthouse Creamery and then Charlie's Lighthouse both in the 80's. Photo: Lighthouse Creamery.
1930 - Earth Origins Market (since about 2012) used to be The Granary from about 1986 to 2012.  Prior to that, it was a Jewel T discount supermarket from 1980 to the mid 80's. At least part of Jewel T had been a Food Fair (1958 to 1969), then Pantry Pride (1969 to 1979) supermarket.
1940 - Carrabba's Italian Grill (since early 1997) used to be the Trolley Station restaurant from 1980 to 1996.
2131 - An empty lot next to Firestone since the late 90's, this used to be Gulf Gate Enco (changed to Exxon in 1972) from the late 60's to about 1984.  Prior to that, it had been Olin's Enco.  From the late 80's to the early-to-mid 90's, this was Gulf Gate Farm Market. Below: Enco station at 2131 Stickney Point Rd.

2480 - Jimmy John's (since 2015) used to be a Dunkin Donuts store (opened in early 2007).  In between, it was a We Buy Gold store.  Previously, a Texaco service station was here from the 60's until the early 00's.  Photo: A new prototype Dunkin Donuts is under construction at 2480 Stickney Point Rd. in October 2006 while the sign from the former Texaco station is still standing
2716 - The Cellular Phone Hospital used to be a Pizza Hut Delivery store from about 1986 before becoming Patellini's Pizza in 1997.

Swift Road
4783 - Simply Gourmet Catering used to be Pizza Pronto, which opened in January 1984.  It would then become Domino's Pizza in 1987, Lola's Empanada's in 1992 and Just Desserts later in the 90's.
5666 - Hot Diggity Dog Restaurant opened in January 1971 and is still here today.

Webber Street
3527 - The Eight-Ball Lounge (since about the mid 70's) used to be Jennie's Steak & Hoagie in the early-to-mid 70's.
3591 - Goodwill Industries (since 1992) used to be a Lil' General food store (mid-to-late 60's to 1984), then Circle K (1984 to 1992).
3602 - The Lazy Parrot Patio Bar & Grill (opening in early 2018) used to be a bank that was built in 1979 as First Independent Bank. It later became First National Bank of Florida, First Florida Bank (mid 80's to 1993) and GTE Credit Union (mid 90's to about 2010).
3644 - Family Pharmacy has been at this location since the late 70's.  Below: Early photo of Family Pharmacy.
3676 - Champion's Pub used to be Oasis Restaurant from about the early 80's to early 90's and then became Tudor Rose Restaurant in 1993. In the 70's, this was Forest Lakes Italian and American Restaurant and even earlier in the late 60's, it was Big John's Pizza Restaurant.


Lost Ads
Here are advertisements from some of the interesting and intriguing business establishments of years gone by in Sarasota.

Lost Ads Of Sarasota

Warwick, RI

It's a long way from Sarasota, but here is a similar site showing how it used to be in Warwick, RI.

What It Used To Be In Warwick, RI


  1. There was a French bakery in the plaza where Simple Sam’s grocery store was located (s. Osprey and Siesta Drive)... do you happen to know the name of the bakery???My grandparents used to purchase desserts there!

    1. Hi Shana, the name of the bakery was The French Hearth.


Post a Comment